There is a manuscript on my hard drive that will probably never be published. It is one of the best things I have ever written.
It is called Not For The Faint of Heart: An Only-Child’s Guide to Grief, and I wrote it while my mother was dying. It came out fast and furious and blinded in tears. Whole chapters arrived in single sittings at three in the morning. I have spent thirty years getting other people’s books out of their heads and onto the page, and I have never written anything with that kind of velocity in my life.
It is staying in the drawer.
That surprises people, so let me be clear about what I am not saying. I am not saying it is bad. The writing is honest and strange and alive in a way that polished writing almost never is. If you handed me that manuscript with someone else’s name on it, I would tell you there was something real in there.
I would also tell you not to publish it. Not yet. Possibly not ever in that shape.
Here is the uncomfortable part. I would have spotted every problem with that book in a ten minute conversation if it had belonged to a client. In my own, it took months, and I only got there once I stopped being the person who wrote it long enough to read it.
The five
Thirty years in this industry and I can count the genuine reasons not to write a book on one hand. Every other objection I have ever heard is fear wearing a costume, and fear is a scheduling problem rather than a reason. These five are real. I managed to hit all of them at the same time.
1. You are in the wound, not the scar
This is the one that got me, and it is the one that gets most memoir writers.
You need distance from an experience to have a point of view about it. Point of view is the entire job. Without it you have a record of what happened, which is a valuable thing to possess and a difficult thing to ask a stranger to read. The reader is not there for the events. The reader is there for what you made of them.
While you are inside the wound, everything feels equally important, because it is. That is what grief does. The trip to the pharmacy carries the same weight as the last conversation. Six months later, or two years later, or ten, some of it recedes and some of it sharpens, and the shape of the thing finally shows up.
You cannot rush that. You can write from inside it, and you should, because the material you capture there is irreplaceable. Writing it and publishing it are two different decisions and you get to make them years apart.
2. You have no clear throughline
Grief has an arc. Every loss does. My book had an arc and that was never the issue.
What it did not have was a spine. One clear thing it was actually about. It was a memoir of my mother, a survival manual for only children, and a set of instructions for the practical horrors nobody warns you about, all wearing the same coat and pretending to be a single book.
Every one of those books deserves to exist. None of them can share a cover. When a reader cannot tell you in one sentence what your book is about, they will not recommend it, a bookseller will not know where to shelve it, and an algorithm will not know who to show it to. The throughline is not a marketing exercise you do at the end. It is the load-bearing wall.
If you cannot say your book in a sentence, you do not have a book yet. You have material, which is further along than most people get.
3. There are legal questions you have not asked yet
Your story has other people in it. They did not sign up for that.
This is the reason writers discover last and at the worst possible moment, usually after the manuscript is finished and someone at a publishing house asks a question that stops everything. Defamation, privacy, contractual obligations from an old job, an estate with more than one beneficiary, a family member who is very much alive and very much recognisable in chapter nine.
None of it means you cannot write the book. It means the questions get answered before page one, when the answers can still shape the work, rather than after page three hundred, when the answers can only break it.
4. The subject needs more eyes than yours
Some material is too sensitive to be handled by one person, and that person is never the one closest to it.
Sensitive work needs a book coach who will tell you the truth about the second act. Sometimes it needs a lawyer. Sometimes it needs a sensitivity read from someone whose life the book touches. Always it needs a reader who is not you, is not your partner, and is not the friend who loves you enough to say it is wonderful.
I would have told any client that within the first hour. I did not tell myself at all, which is a fairly humbling way to learn that expertise does not extend to your own blind spots.
5. You missed the moment, or you are early
Publishing runs on a delay. A traditionally published book acquired today arrives in eighteen months to two years, and by then the conversation has moved. Books that chase a trend arrive to find the room empty.
The reverse happens too, and it hurts more. You finish something genuinely good and the world is simply not ready to hear it yet. The topic is too raw, or too crowded, or the news cycle has made your subject radioactive for a season. That is not a verdict on the writing. It is weather.
Weather changes. A finished manuscript keeps. Timing is the one variable in this entire business that patience actually fixes.
What this is really about
Every one of these five reasons is a reason not to write the book now. Not one of them is a reason to never write it.
That distinction is the whole thing. The writers I work with tend to hear “not yet” as “no,” which is why so many of them either publish something before it is ready or abandon a book that only needed another year. Both of those are avoidable, and both of them are decided long before anyone starts writing, in the conversation about whether this is the right book for the right reader at the right moment.
I ask three questions before I take on any project. Is this the book. Is this the moment. Is this the shape. My grief book passed the first one and failed the other two, and I did not find that out until I had written the whole thing.
A drawer is not a failure. A drawer is a decision.
Mine is made on purpose. Make yours on purpose too.
Your Next Fave Read
- How Do I Know If My Story Is Worth a Book?
- How to Write About Real People in Your Book: The Complete Guide for Memoir and Nonfiction Authors
- Do You Need a Book Coach? Seven Signs, and One Uncomfortable Truth
Ready to get your wisdom into the world, however you write it? Book a free validation call. We will figure out the right approach for your specific book and your goals, whether that is coaching, ghostwriting, or collaboration.
