Group Retreat or Private 1:1: Which One Is Actually Right for You
Both work. They don’t work for the same person, or the same reason.
People ask me which is “better,” the group retreat or private 1:1 coaching. Wrong question. They’re built for different problems, and picking the wrong one is how you end up paying for the right kind of help delivered in the wrong format.
What a Group Retreat Actually Gives You
Six writers in a room, a fixed weekend, a shared deadline, and the kind of accountability that only shows up when other people can see whether you did the work. You also get the energy of watching five other people fight through the same resistance you’re fighting, which does something a solo Zoom call never will.
What Private 1:1 Actually Gives You
Undivided attention on your specific manuscript, on your timeline, without sharing coaching hours with anyone else. It’s the right call when your book has specific complexity, a sensitive subject, or a timeline that doesn’t line up with a scheduled retreat date.
Who Should Choose the Group Retreat
Writers who thrive on deadlines with witnesses, who want the momentum of a room full of people also mid-book, and who don’t need every single hour of coaching pointed at them to make real progress.
Who Should Choose Private 1:1
Writers with a book complex enough to need dedicated, undivided time, or a schedule that genuinely can’t bend to a fixed retreat date, or a subject matter that needs a more private working relationship than a group room allows.
Cost, Timing, and Logistics
Beyond the coaching itself, the two formats ask different things of your calendar and your budget. A group retreat is a fixed date in a fixed place, which means travel and time off booked in advance, but also a single, contained investment and a hard deadline that does a lot of the motivational work for you. Private 1:1 is built around your schedule and can often happen without travel at all, but it asks more of your self-discipline, because there’s no room full of people noticing whether you showed up. Neither is cheaper in a way that matters; they’re priced for different amounts of one-on-one time. Choose the format that removes your actual obstacle, not the one that looks like a better deal on paper.
Can You Do Both?
Plenty of writers do, and in a specific order that works: the group retreat to break the back of the draft and build momentum, then private 1:1 afterward to push a complicated manuscript the rest of the way home. If you’re torn, that sequence is often the honest answer, start in the room, then go one-on-one for the finish.
The Honest Answer
If you’re not sure, the group retreat is the lower-risk starting point for most writers. You get structure, accountability, and coaching, at a fixed cost and a fixed weekend. Private 1:1 exists for the cases the retreat format genuinely can’t serve.
Not Sure Which Fits? Ask.
Every application includes a call with me first, specifically to figure out which format is actually right for your book.
Start Your Application
